Triboelectrostatic separation has been used for the commercial beneficiation of coal combustion fly ash to produce a low carbon product for use as a cement replacement in concrete for nearly twenty years…. STET’s patented electrostatic separator has been used to produce over 15 Million tonnes of low carbon product…Recent environmental legislation…coupled with a requirement …to empty historical landfill sites, has created the need to develop a process to beneficiate historically landfilled ash…
পিডিএফ ডাউনলোড করুনTriboelectrostatic Beneficiation of
Land Filled Fly Ash
L. বেকার, এ. গুপ্ত, এবং. Gasiorowski
উপজাতি সরঞ্জাম & টেকনোলজিস এলএলসি, 101 হ্যাম্পটন অ্যাভিনিউ, নিডম মা 02494 আমেরিকা
CONFERENCE: 2015 World of Coal Ash – (www.worldofcoalash.org)
কী-ওয়ার্ড: Triboelectrostatic, Beneficiation, ছাই উড়ে, Landfilled, Dried, বিচ্ছেদ, কার্বন
বিমূর্ত
Triboelectrostatic separation has been used for the commercial beneficiation of coal combustion fly ash to produce a low carbon product for use as a cement replacement in concrete for nearly twenty years. With 18 separators in 12 coal-fired power plants across the world, উপজাতি সরঞ্জাম & প্রযুক্তি এলএলসি (স্ট্যান্ড) patented electrostatic separator has been used to produce over 15 Million tonnes of low carbon product.
To date, commercial beneficiation of fly ash has been performed exclusively on dry “run of station‿ ash. Recent environmental legislation has created, in certain markets, a need to supply beneficiated ash in times of low ash generation. এই, coupled with a requirement in some locations to empty historical ash landfill sites, has created the need to develop a process to beneficiate historically landfilled ash.
Previous studies have shown that the exposure of fly ash to moisture, and subsequent drying influences the triboelectrostatic charging mechanism, with carbon and mineral particles charging in the opposite polarity to that experienced with run of station ash. Studies have been performed by the authors to determine the effect of moisture exposure on separation efficiency of several ashes that have been reclaimed from landfills and dried. Charge reversal was experienced following drying, but overall separation efficiency was achieved equivalent to that experienced with fresh run of station ash.
The effect of dried ash feed relative humidity on triboelectrostatic separation efficiency was examined, and sensitivity was greatly reduced compared to that experienced with run of station ash, lowering overall process costs.
ভূমিকা
আমেরিকান কয়লার ছাই এসোসিয়েশন (ACAA) বার্ষিক জরিপের উৎপাদন ও কয়লা মাছি ছাই ব্যবহার মধ্যে রিপোর্ট 1966 এবং 2011, উপরে 2.3 billion short tons of fly ash have been produced by coal-fired utility boilers.1 Of this amount approximately 625 লক্ষ লক্ষ টন beneficially ব্যবহার করা হয়েছে, মূলত সিমেন্ট ও কনক্রিট উৎপাদনের জন্য. তবে, অবশিষ্ট আছে 1.7+ billion tons are primarily found in landfills or filled ponded
impoundments. While utilization rates for freshly generated fly ash have increased considerably over recent years, with current rates near 45%, প্রায় 40 million tons of fly ash continue to be disposed of annually. While utilization rates in Europe have been much higher than in the US, considerable volumes of fly ash have also been stored in landfills and impoundments in some European countries.
সম্প্রতি, interest in recovering this disposed material has increased, partially due to the demand for high-quality fly ash for concrete and cement production during a period of reduced production as coal-fired power generation has decreased in Europe and North America. Concerns about the long-term environmental impact of such landfills are also prompting utilities to find beneficial use applications for this stored ash.
LAND FILLED ASH QUALITY AND REQUIRED BENEFICIATION
While some of this stored fly ash may be suitable for beneficial use as initially excavated, the vast majority will require some processing to meet quality standards for cement or concrete production. Since the material has been typically wetted to enable handling and compaction while avoiding airborne dust generation, drying will probably be a minimal requirement for use in concrete since concrete producers will want to continue the practice of batching fly ash as a dry powder. তবে, assuring the chemical composition of the ash meets specifications, most notably the carbon content measured as loss-on-ignition (LOI), is a greater challenge. As fly ash utilization has increased in the last 20+ বছর, most “in-spec‿ ash has been beneficially used, and the off-quality ash disposed. Thus, LOI reduction will be a requirement for utilizing the vast majority of fly ash recoverable from utility impoundments.
LOI REDUCTION BY TRIBOELECTRIC SEPARATION
While various workers have used combustion techniques and flotation processes for LOI reduction of recovered landfilled and ponded fly ash, উপজাতি সরঞ্জাম & Technologies (স্ট্যান্ড) has found that its standard processing system, তাজা উত্পন্ন ফ্লাই অ্যাশের উপকারের জন্য দীর্ঘ ব্যবহৃত, is equally effective on recovered ash after suitable drying and deagglomeration at lower overall operating costs.
During the ramp-up to commercial application of the STET processing system for fly ash, STET researchers tested the separation of dried landfilled ash. এই উদ্ধার করা ছাইটি একটি বিস্ময়কর পার্থক্যের সাথে তাজা উত্পন্ন ছাইয়ের সাথে খুব একইভাবে পৃথক করা হয়েছে: কণা চার্জিং খনিজ সম্পর্কিত কার্বন চার্জিং নেতিবাচক সঙ্গে তাজা ছাই যে থেকে বিপরীত ছিল.2 ফ্লাই অ্যাশ কার্বনের ইলেক্ট্রোস্ট্যাটিক বিচ্ছেদের অন্যান্য গবেষকরাও এই ঘটনাটি পর্যবেক্ষণ করেছেন.3,4,5
TECHNOLOGY OVERVIEW – FLY ASH CARBON SEPARATION
In the STET carbon separator (চরিত্র 1), material is fed into the thin gap between two parallel planar electrodes. কণা triboelectrically interparticle যোগাযোগ করে চার্জ প্রযোজ্য হবে. The positively charged carbon and the negatively charged mineral (in freshly generated ash that has not been wetted and dried) বিপরীত ইলেকট্রোড আকৃষ্ট হয়. The particles are then swept up by a continuous moving belt and conveyed in opposite directions. কণা বিপরীত পৃথকীকরণ শেষ দিকে প্রতিটি তড়িদ্দ্বার সংলগ্ন বেল্ট চাল. বেল্ট উচ্চ গতি খুব বেশি throughputs সক্ষম করে, তোমার উপর 36 টন ওজনের একক বিভাজক প্রতি ঘন্টায়. ছোট ফাঁক, high voltage field, প্রবাহ, vigorous particle-particle agitation and self-cleaning action of the belt on the electrodes are the critical features of the STET separator. বিভিন্ন প্রক্রিয়া পরামিতি নিয়ন্ত্রণ করা হচ্ছে, বেল্ট গতি যেমন, বিন্দু ফিড, এবং ফিড রেট, এসটিইটি প্রক্রিয়াটি কম এলওআই ফ্লাই অ্যাশ উত্পাদন করে কার্বন সামগ্রীতে কম 1.5 প্রতি 4.5% from feed fly ashes ranging in LOI from 4% থেকে বেশী 25%.
Fig. 1 STET Separator
The separator design is relatively simple and compact. একটি মেশিন প্রক্রিয়া করার জন্য ডিজাইন করা হয়েছে 36 প্রতি ঘন্টায় টন প্রায় 9 m (30 ফুট) দীর্ঘ, 1.5 m (5 ফুট) প্রশস্ত, এবং 2.75 m (9 ফুট) উচ্চ. বেল্ট ও সংশ্লিষ্ট rollers একমাত্র প্রশাখা রয়েছে. ~ যেন সায়ানাইডকে নিশ্চল ও সেল্ফ মজবুত পদার্থ গঠিত হয়।. The belt is made of non- conductive plastic. The separator’s power consumption is about 1 বেল্ট চালানো দুটি মোটর দ্বারা ব্যবহৃত বেশিরভাগ বিদ্যুৎ সঙ্গে প্রতি টন উপাদান কিলোওয়াট-ঘন্টা.
প্রক্রিয়াটি পুরোপুরি শুষ্ক, requires no additional materials other than the fly ash and produces no waste water or air emissions. The recovered materials consist of fly ash reduced in carbon content to levels suitable for use as a pozzolanic admixture in
কংক্রিট, and a high carbon fraction useful as fuel. উভয় পণ্য প্রবাহের ব্যবহার একটি প্রদান করে 100% উড়ন্ত ছাই নিষ্কাশন সমস্যা.
RECOVERED FUEL VALUE OF HIGH-CARBON FLY ASH
In addition to the low carbon product for use in concrete, brand named ProAsh®, the STET separation process also recovers otherwise wasted unburned carbon in the form of carbon-rich fly ash, branded EcoTherm™. EcoTherm™ has significant fuel value and can easily be returned to the electric power plant using the STET EcoTherm™ Return system to reduce the coal use at the plant. When EcoTherm™ is burned in the utility boiler, the energy from combustion is converted to high pressure / high temperature steam and then to electricity at the same efficiency as coal, typically 35%. The conversion of the recovered thermal energy to electricity in ST Equipment & Technology LLC EcoTherm™ Return system is two to three times higher than that of the competitive technology where the energy is recovered as low-grade heat in the form of hot water which is circulated to the boiler feed water system. EcoTherm™ is also used as a source of alumina in cement kilns, displacing the more expensive bauxite which is usually transported long distances. Utilizing the high carbon EcoTherm™ ash either at a power plant or a cement kiln, maximizes the energy recovery from the delivered coal, reducing the need to mine and transport additional fuel to the facilities.
STET’s Raven Power Brandon Shores, SMEPA R.D. আগামীকাল, NBP Belledune, RWEnpower Didcot, EDF Energy West Burton, and RWEnpower Aberthaw fly ash plants, all include EcoTherm™ Return systems. The essential components of the system are presented in Figure 2.
Fig. 2 EcoTherm™ Return system
STET ASH PROCESING FACILITIES
Controlled low LOI fly ash is produced with STET’s technology at twelve power stations throughout the U.S., কানাডা, the U.K., পোল্যান্ড, and Republic of Korea. ProAsh® fly ash has been approved for use by over twenty state highway authorities, পাশাপাশি অন্যান্য অনেক স্পেসিফিকেশন এজেন্সি. ProAsh® has also been certified under Canadian Standards Association and EN 450:2005 ইউরোপে গুণগত মান. Ash processing facilities using STET technology are listed in Table 1.
টেবিল 1. STET Commercial Operations
উপযোগ / Power Station |
অবস্থান |
Start of Commercial operations |
Facility Details |
Progress Energy – Roxboro Station |
নর্থ ক্যারোলিনা ইউএসএ |
Sept. 1997 |
2 বিভাজক |
রেভেন পাওয়ার – Brandon Shores Station |
মেরিল্যান্ড ইউএসএ |
এপ্রিল 1999 |
2 বিভাজক 35,000 ton storage dome. Ecotherm™ Return 2008 |
ScotAsh (Lafarge / Scottish Power Joint Venture) – লঙ্গানেট স্টেশন |
স্কটল্যান্ড যুক্তরাজ্য |
অক্টোবর. 2002 |
1 বিভাজক |
Jacksonville Electric Authority – St. John’s River Power Park,FL |
ফ্লোরিডা ইউএসএ |
মে 2003 |
2 Separators Coal/Petcoke blends Ammonia Removal |
South Mississippi Electric Power Authority R.D. Morrow Station |
মিসিসিপি ইউএসএ |
Jan. 2005 |
1 Separator Ecotherm™ Return |
New Brunswick Power Company Belledune Station |
New Brunswick, কানাডা |
এপ্রিল 2005 |
1 Separator Coal/Petcoke Blends Ecotherm™ Return |
RWE npower Didcot Station |
ইংল্যান্ড যুক্তরাজ্য |
আগস্ট 2005 |
1 Separator Ecotherm™ Return |
PPL Brunner Island Station |
পেনসিলভানিয়া ইউএসএ |
ডিসেম্বর 2006 |
2 বিভাজক 40,000 Ton storage dome |
Tampa Electric Co. Big Bend Station |
ফ্লোরিডা ইউএসএ |
এপ্রিল 2008 |
3 বিভাজক, দ্বৈত 25,000 Ton storage dome Ammonia Removal |
RWE npower Aberthaw Station (Lafarge Cement UK) |
ওয়েলস ইউকে |
সেপ্টেম্বর 2008 |
1 Separator Ammonia Removal Ecotherm™ Return |
EDF Energy West Burton Station (Lafarge Cement UK, Cemex) |
ইংল্যান্ড যুক্তরাজ্য |
অক্টোবর 2008 |
1 Separator Ecotherm™ Return |
জেডজিপি (লাফার্জ সিমেন্ট পোল্যান্ড / সিচ জানিকোসোদা জেভি) |
পোল্যান্ড |
মার্চ 2010 |
1 বিভাজক |
Korea South-East Power Yeongheung Units 5&6 |
দক্ষিণ কোরিয়া |
সেপ্টেম্বর 2014 |
1 Separator Ecotherm™ Return |
COAL ASH RECOVERED FROM LAND FILLS
Two sources of ash were obtained from landfills: sample A from a power plant located in
the United Kingdom and sample B: from the United States. Both these samples consisted of ash from the combustion of bituminous coal by large utility boilers. Due to the intermingling of material in the landfills, no further information is available concerning specific coal source or combustion conditions.
The samples as received by STET contained between 15% এবং 20% water as is typical for landfilled material. The samples also contained varying amounts of large >1/8 ইঞ্চি (~3 mm) material. To prepare the samples for carbon separation, the large debris was removed by screening and the samples then dried and deagglomerated prior to carbon beneficiation. Various methods for drying/deagglomeration are being evaluated in order to optimize the overall process. A general process flow sheet is presented in Figure 3.
চরিত্র 3: Process flow sheet
The properties of the prepared samples were well within the range of fly ash obtained directly from normal utility boilers. The most relevant properties for both the separator feeds and products are summarized in Table 2 along with recovered product.
CARBON SEPARATION
Carbon reduction trials using the STET triboelectric belt separator resulted in very good recovery of low LOI product. The interesting phenomena observed was the reversal of charging of the carbon discussed above. While this behavior has been observed previously by STET and other researchers, the mechanism that changes the relative work functions and thus contact charging behavior of the material is not understood. One suggested mechanism is the redistribution of soluble ions on the mineral and
carbon particles, possibly further influenced by the pH of the aqueous solution on the ash4. Whatever the fundamental mechanism is, it does not appear to degrade the practical application of triboelectric separation to reduce the carbon content of the ash.
বয়লার থেকে সদ্য সংগৃহীত ছাই এবং ল্যান্ডফিল থেকে উদ্ধার করা ছাই উভয়ের জন্য এসটিইটি প্রক্রিয়া ব্যবহার করে উদ্ধার করা কম এলওআই ফ্লাই অ্যাশের বৈশিষ্ট্যগুলি সারণীতে সারসংক্ষেপ করা হয়েছে
2.The results show that the STET process efficiency for the recovered landfill ash is within the range expected for ash freshly collected from the utility boiler.
টেবিল 2: Properties of feed and recovered low-LOI ash.
বিভাজককে নমুনা ফিড করুন |
LOI |
ProAsh LOI® |
ProAsh Fineness, %® +45 µm |
ProAsh® ভর ফলন |
EcoTherm® High Carbon Product |
তাজা A |
10.2 % |
3.6 % |
23 % |
84 % |
39 % |
ল্যান্ডফিল A |
9.8 % |
3.3 % |
20 % |
75 % |
28 % |
তাজা B |
5.3 % |
2.8 % |
17 % |
91 % |
28 % |
Landfill B |
6.9 % |
4.5 % |
24 % |
86 % |
26 % |
PROCESS ECONOMICS
In addition to the normal costs of the STET process, the cost of drying the recovered, high moisture content ash will increase the overall operating costs of the process. টেবিল 3 summarizes the fuel costs for both operations in the USA and UK for 15% এবং 20% moisture contents. Typical inefficiencies of drying are included in the calculated values. Costs are based on the mass of material after drying.
টেবিল 3: Drying costs on basis of dried mass.
Moisture content | Heat Requirement KWhr/t | Drying cost / T dry basis UK | Drying cost / T dry basis US |
---|---|---|---|
Gas cost 0.027 £/kWhr | Gas cost $4.75 / mmBtu | ||
15 % | 165 | £ 5.24 | £ 1.94 |
£ 8.48 | £ 3.14 | ||
£ 6.73 | £ 2.49 | ||
20 % | 217 | £ 7.23 | £ 2.71 |
£ 11.85 | £ 4.39 | ||
£ 9.40 | £ 3.48 |
ASH CHEMISTRY AND PERFORMANCE IN CONCRETE
The properties of the low carbon ash generated from the dried landfill material were compared to that of freshly obtained ash to check the suitability for use in concrete production. এই
following table summarizes the chemistry for samples from source B. Testing on source A material has not been completed.
টেবিল 4: Ash Chemistry of low LOI ash.
Source B material |
SiO2 |
আল২ও৩ |
Fe2O3 |
সিএও |
MgO |
K2O |
Na2O |
SO3 |
Fresh Production |
51.60 |
24.70 |
9.9 |
2.22 |
0.85 |
2.19 |
0.28 |
0.09 |
Landfilled |
50.40 |
25.00 |
9.3 |
3.04 |
0.85 |
2.41 |
0.21 |
0.11 |
Strength development of a 20% substitution of the low LOI fly ash in a mortar containing 600 lb / yd3 showed the material derived from landfilled ash performed somewhat better than material from fresh production. টেবিল দেখুন 5 নিচে.
টেবিল 5: Compressive strength of mortar cubes.
|
7 day Compressive Strength PSI |
28 day Compressive Strength PSI |
Fresh |
3948 |
5185 |
Landfilled |
4254 |
5855 |
CONCLUSIONS
After suitable scalping of large material, drying, and deagglomeration, fly ash recovered from utility plant landfills can be reduced in carbon content using the commercialized STET triboelectric belt separator. The efficiency of the STET system is essentially equivalent for ashes obtained freshly from boiler operations and dried landfilled material. The separator product is suitable for use in concrete production without further beneficiation with nearly identical performance properties. The recovery and beneficiation of landfilled ash will provide a continuing supply of high quality ash for concrete producers in spite of the reduced production of “fresh‿ ash as coal-fired utilities reduce generation. উপরন্তু, power plants that need to remove ash from landfills to meet changing environmental regulations will be able to utilize the process to alter a waste product liability into a valuable raw material for concrete producers.
তথ্যসূত্র
[1]American Coal Ash Coal Combustion products and Use Statistics: https://www.acaa-usa.org/Publications/Production-Use-Reports/
[2]ST internal report, আগস্ট 1995.
[3]লি,T.X,. শেফার, J.L., নিষিদ্ধ, H., নেথারি, J.K., and Stencel, J.M. Dry Beneficiation Processing of Combustion Fly Ash, Proceedings of the DOE Conference on Unburned Carbon on Utility Fly Ash, মে 19 20, Pittsburgh, PA, 1998.
[4]Baltrus, J.P., Diehl, J.R., Soong, Y., Sands, W. Triboelectrostatic separation of fly ash and charge reversal, Fuel 81, (2002) pp.757-762.
[5]Cangialosi, F., Notarnicola, M., Liberti, L, স্টেনসেল, জে. The role of weathering on fly ash charge distribution during triboelectrostatic beneficiation, Journal of Hazardous Materials, 164 (2009) pp.683-688.
Word to PDF Converter Converted By BCLTechnologies